Anal Amy

That prom night started out pretty interesting. During the prom me and my date, Vinny found unused banquet room and had sex on one of the tables. He just pushed my dress up, took my panties off then we fucked. I think he lasted all of a minute. Then I put my panties back on, fixed my dress and we went back to the prom.

When we got back one of his friends that I was kind of friends with asked if he could dance with me. The dance got pretty hot and heavy, Tom was grinding against me so much that he got a few dirty looks from one of the teachers. Of course that didn't stop us. At one point, he whispered into my ear "Amy I want you so bad." I said something like maybe later tonight.

When I got back to Vinny he interrogated me about it. At first I thought he was mad but then he started to ask me questions like "do you want to have sex with Tom?" And I said things like "maybe." Not giving too many definite answers.

But I kind of forgot about it. I didn't see him much after that at the prom and after the prom he went to a different after party. I went with Vinny to some after party which was basically just a place to drink some and change before we went out.

We went to this under 21 club that didn't serve alcohol. I don't need alcohol to have fun but this place was boring without alcohol. Luckily, we were able to sneak some liquor in but not nearly enough for all of our group.

I remember I was dancing with Vinny and my mini skirt kept rising up so that the straps of my garter belt kept becoming visible. I kept pulling my skirt down for a while but then I gave up.

Vinny noticed but so did a few other guys. Watching them try to get peeks or even staring at my legs really turned me on.

When the club closed a small group of us went to a hotel for one final party. We did some more drinking but I was still pretty sober when Tom showed up without his prom date.

It wasn't long after that the three of us were going back to a room Vinny had rented. At first it seemed like nothing was going to happen, we were just sitting on the bed watching tv. I was waiting for one of them to make the first move. I was really too nervous to do it.

Then Tom asked if we were going to do this or not. It was kind of funny and broke the silence.

I said something like "I want both of you to take turns fucking me." Except whatever I said sounded a lot more naughty and sexy.

My clothes came off except my gaterbelt and stockings. Vinny wanted me to keep them on. There wasn't any foreplay. I don't even think I was felt up until after we were already having sex and that's always something guys will do as soon as my bra comes off.

I just got into the doggy style position and really didn't do much after that.

We had done anal a few times already and I knew what he wanted. He pushed his cock against my ass. He had problem getting in me. We weren't using any kind of lube so it took a little effort from both of us to get him into me. And at first it hurt, but the kind of pain that made me moan a little.

He lasted a lot longer this time. It still wasn't great sex, but I think we both enjoyed it.

It wasn't great sex, I was still what I would call a "boring fuck" back then. I just laid there while he fucked me. But he wasn't that great either. But at least he lasted longer than a minute.

I felt like such a slut - having two guys alone with me in the room.

Tom replaced him and put his cock into my ass. It was pretty easy having him enter me. He told me I was his first for anal sex.

It felt so weird having two different cocks into me one after another. They felt different, they fucked me different. Tom was pretty gentle until he started getting close. Then for a minute he fucked me hard until he came.

If it hadn't been like five in the morning I think we would've kept going.